Frozen vs Freeze Dried Fish Food – What is the Difference?
Disclosure: I may earn a commission when you purchase through my affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. – read more
Things aren’t easy or clear when it comes to feeding your tank fish. Different fish have different dietary requirements and eating habits.
In many cases, even members of the same species will differ in their food preferences because fish are unique animals that often come with different predilections.
What’s the main difference between them, and which is more beneficial to your fish? Let’s see!
What is Frozen Fish Food?
Frozen fish food is typically packed with a lot of nutrients and offers fish a high protein content. Most frozen fish food options combine several food sources, along with a variety of added vitamins and minerals for optimized nutrition.
These products are great for picky fish species that require a more carefully-planned meal plan.
Overall, the main benefit of frozen fish food products is that they retain more nutrients than other options. Aside from living foods, of course.
What is Freeze-Dried Fish Food?
Freeze-dried foods are specialized in the sense that they each only contain one ingredient instead of multiple.
They’re the freeze-dried version of live foods with minimal processing but lower nutritional value as well.
Some of the ingredients used include bloodworms, cyclops, tubifex worms, brine shrimp, etc.
Frozen vs. Freeze-Dried Food – Differences and Similarities
While both of these food types provide fish with vital nutrients, there are some differences between them that are worth mentioning.
Consider the following:
Frozen foods are more impactful, nutritionally speaking. This is because they combine several food options, along with vitamins and minerals, to ensure a more nutritious and fulfilling mix.
In other words, you can easily rely on frozen foods alone to feed your fish, provided your product of choice has all the macros that the animal needs.
It’s also worth mentioning that frozen foods retain much more nutrients thanks to the freezing method.
Freeze-dried foods are more circumstantial, as most people use them to supplement their fish’s diet. So, if you’re already feeding your fish a herbivorous or omnivorous diet and need some protein snacks occasionally, freeze-dried foods are great in this sense.
You can simply choose your fish’s favorite meal, like brine shrimp, for instance, and offer occasional treats to complement their meal plan.
Unfortunately, freeze-dried foods pack fewer nutrients due to the more aggressive processing technique. The freeze-drying method destroys more of the protein than freezing the meal does.
Overall, most aquarists have declared that frozen foods are superior in terms of taste to freeze-dried foods. This makes sense, too, given that the fresh food is frozen fast, allowing the freezing process to retain much of the food’s properties, including the aroma.
Once the meal is placed into the water and begins to unfreeze, the fish will immediately sense the taste and odors of the fresh nutrients. The key is to pick the optimal meal for your fish since not all fish love the same frozen products.
Freeze-dried foods have a duller smell and taste due to the drying process eliminating the moisture and making the food blander.
Fortunately, the drying process also prolongs the product’s lifespan, so that’s clearly a plus worth mentioning.
Fouling the Water
Unfortunately, as nutritious and tasty frozen foods, they also foul the water much faster. That’s because these are live foods that still have all their moisture and meatiness.
Once they unfreeze and fish start eating them, particles will spread out through the environment, especially if you’re feeding messy and energetic eaters.
Freeze-dried foods are more compact since they have no moisture. You can easily crumble them between your fingers and sprinkle the food across the water’s surface.
The broken flakes will take up humidity, but the fish will consume everything before the product can begin to decay.
As you can tell, there are some notable differences between frozen and freeze-dried foods. The former are more nutritious but foul the water more and don’t last as much. It’s also easier to overfeed your fish with frozen meals.
The latter doesn’t pack as many nutrients but is more environmentally friendly and has a longer lifespan.
Frozen or Freeze-Dried Food is Best for Fish?
While both of these food types are circumstantial, it’s worth noting that most aquarists prefer frozen foods over freeze-dried ones.
That being said, there is a moment and a place for freeze-dried products as well, depending on the situation.
So, let’s summarize each option’s pros and cons:
Frozen Food Pros:
- More nutrient-packed, as it combines several food sources and vitamins and minerals for a more nutritious mix
- Easier to consume, and fish love it more thanks to the more intense and natural taste and odor
- Are often sufficient as a standalone meal for fish thanks to the optimized nutrient content
- Helps fish remain healthier and more colorful and boosts their growth rate
Frozen Food Cons:
- You can only store the frozen fish food for approximately 6 months, although some versions degrade faster, while others last longer
- Frozen foods foul the water more
Freeze-Dried Food Pros:
- Doesn’t foul the water as much, as the food is devoid of moisture and doesn’t break down into smaller particles when immersed into the water
- Allows for a more specialized diet as it often comprises of a single ingredient
- Most fish eat freeze-dried foods, especially since they don’t have any specific smell that would repel some fish species
- It lasts a lot more than frozen foods, typically more than 2 years, depending on the manufacturer and the food itself
Freeze-Dried Food Pros:
- It cannot form a well-rounded diet by itself, as it’s incomplete in terms of nutrient content
- It’s not as palatable as other foods, so fish aren’t exactly exhilarated to eat it
Ultimately, I think you can find a way to incorporate both of these meal options into your fish’s diet. It all boils down to your species of aquarium fish and how their meal plan is structured.
Frozen and freeze-dried foods both have their place in the grand scheme of things.
As a general idea, freeze-dried foods are more useful when feeding omnivorous or herbivorous fish that only need protein treats 2-3 times per week.
Frozen foods are more fitting for fish demanding higher-protein meals because they’re more well-rounded, nutritionally speaking.